Pretrial detention is one of the most severe measures employed in criminal proceedings, and it must be accompanied by strict adherence to the rights of defendants and their legal representatives. In such cases, it is especially critical that attorneys working with detainees in pretrial detention facilities (SIZO) have the ability to effectively defend their clients. However, in practice, there are frequent instances of violations of their professional rights, significantly weakening the quality of legal defense. This issue is particularly pressing amid the current political climate in Russia and worldwide, characterized by increasing authoritarian tendencies, heightened government censorship, and a growing number of politically motivated cases. These factors exacerbate the problem and underscore the need for greater focus on protecting attorneys' rights and their professional independence.
Professional Rights of Attorneys
In Russia, the rights of attorneys are safeguarded under Federal Law No. 63-FZ "On Advocacy and the Bar in the Russian Federation." This law outlines several key rights aimed at enabling attorneys to effectively represent their clients:
- Confidential client meetings: Discussions between an attorney and their client must not be monitored or recorded, ensuring the protection of private information and fostering trust.
- Unrestricted client access: Attorneys have the right to meet their clients at any time to discuss case matters, which is fundamental for adequate defense preparation.
- Exercise of legal authority: Attorneys may use all lawful means to protect their clients' rights, ensuring compliance with legal norms for both the defendant and themselves.
These rights are vital for ensuring fairness in criminal proceedings and guaranteeing the defendant's rights. However, violations of these rights significantly undermine the quality of legal defense. In recent years, Russia has seen increased political instability and pressure on attorneys working on cases involving anti-war protests or opposition activities. Under intensified censorship and repression against political dissent, attorneys face significant barriers that hinder their ability to act in their clients' best interests.
Types of Violations of Attorneys' Professional Rights
Attorneys working in pretrial detention facilities encounter numerous violations of their professional rights, impeding their ability to effectively defend their clients. Common violations include:
- Restricted access to clients: This violation manifests in several forms:
- Requiring additional documentation not mandated by law (e.g., permission from investigators or the court).
- Complications with scheduling client meetings through electronic systems due to technical issues.
- Prolonged wait times at detention facility entrances or during client transfers, reducing the attorney's ability to prepare an effective defense.
These obstacles are particularly severe in politically sensitive cases, where delays or denials of access are used to obstruct defense efforts.
-
Interrupted meetings: Attorneys' meetings with clients may be abruptly terminated without explanation. Such interruptions violate attorneys' rights to communicate freely with their clients and disrupt case preparation. In some instances, these interruptions are used as a means of exerting pressure on the attorney, further hindering effective legal assistance.
-
Violation of confidentiality: Conversations between attorneys and clients are sometimes unlawfully monitored or recorded. Such practices directly violate the law, but they persist, especially in cases involving allegations of "spreading false information" about the Russian armed forces. These breaches of confidentiality erode trust between attorneys and their clients, compromising the integrity of the defense.
-
Seizure of legal materials: During attorney-client meetings, notes or other materials created by the attorney may be confiscated. This constitutes a serious violation of professional rights, as these materials can be used against the client, breaching attorney-client privilege and undermining the right to defense.
These violations impede attorneys from providing competent legal assistance, adversely affecting the rights of defendants. International organizations, including Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch, have repeatedly called attention to the need for protecting attorneys' independence and rights, particularly in the context of increasing censorship and political repression in Russia.
International Reactions and Recommendations
Under international standards, attorneys' rights must be protected against any interference in their professional activities. The United Nations Basic Principles on the Role of Lawyers assert that attorneys must not face reprisals, threats, or arbitrary restrictions, and their professional activities must be fully supported. Organizations such as the European Court of Human Rights have also emphasized the importance of protecting attorneys' rights in countries where legal professionals face systemic interference.
To improve the situation in Russia, comprehensive measures are necessary to strengthen attorneys' independence, ensure their safety, and prevent interference in their professional work. Establishing monitoring systems to oversee compliance with attorneys' rights and creating mechanisms for international advocacy are crucial steps toward safeguarding justice and human rights in the country.
The protection of attorneys' rights is an integral component of ensuring fairness in criminal proceedings. Violations of these rights, particularly in the context of political instability and repression of dissent, undermine trust in the legal system and limit defendants' ability to receive adequate representation. It is essential for the international community to maintain pressure on authorities while domestic reforms focus on safeguarding attorneys' independence and countering repression. Only then can the rights of citizens be adequately defended, and justice remain impartial.
V. Ivanenko, Legal Advocate and Human Rights Defender